The Emperor's New Clothes: A Timeless Lesson on Leadership and Psychological Safety
Hans Christian Andersen's timeless tale, The Emperor's New Clothes, offers more than just a whimsical story of vanity and deception; it imparts valuable lessons on leadership and the importance of psychological safety in the workplace. The story, centered around an emperor who is duped into parading in invisible clothes, underscores fundamental principles that are crucial for fostering a culture where truth and feedback are valued.
In Andersen’s tale, an emperor, obsessed with his appearance, is convinced by two swindlers that they can create the finest clothes made from a fabric that is invisible to anyone who is either unfit for their position or “hopelessly stupid.” The emperor, fearing that he might be deemed unworthy or foolish, pretends to see the clothes and parades through the town in his new “garments.” It is only when a child innocently points out that the emperor is, in fact, wearing nothing at all that the truth is revealed.
Openness and Intellectual Humility
The emperor's refusal to admit his ignorance, coupled with his fear of appearing foolish, prevents him from acknowledging the truth. Leaders can avoid this pitfall by modeling vulnerability and openness. When leaders admit their own mistakes and show a willingness to learn, it encourages a culture where employees feel empowered to speak up without fear of ridicule. Leaders who demonstrate that they value honesty and are open to feedback set a powerful example for their teams.
When I think of my worst workplace experiences, they are directly connected to a leader who lacked intellectual humility, or the ability to admit they don’t have all the answers. We all have knowledge gaps, and we should seek input and the expertise that others can provide. When we value collaboration, we create a more dynamic and resilient organization and can handle problems and challenges more effectively. I also failed in these situations. I was much like the people in the town who said nothing.
Creating Psychological Safety
The emperor's downfall stems from his inability to receive honest feedback. The swindlers exploit this by preying on his vanity and fear of being judged. Similarly, leaders who do not foster an environment of psychological safety may discourage honest feedback, either through overt actions or subtle cues. When employees fear repercussions or are uncomfortable sharing their true opinions, problems go unaddressed, and the organization suffers from a lack of transparency and trust.
Psychological safety, a concept popularized by Harvard Business School professor Amy Edmondson, refers to an environment where individuals feel safe to speak up without fear of negative consequences. Leaders can create this environment by actively inviting feedback, responding to criticism with openness, and acknowledging mistakes. In the story, the emperor’s failure to create a safe space for dissenting opinions leads to his public embarrassment.
A leader who fosters psychological safety ensures that employees feel comfortable sharing their concerns, ideas, and constructive criticism. Times I didn’t say anything, but should have, were times I didn’t feel safe. If a leader had asked my opinion and made me feel comfortable giving it, I would have had a lot to say.
Trust and Transparency
The emperor’s lack of self-awareness and the consequent deception that unfolds in the story could have been avoided if he had established a culture of trust and transparency. Trust is built through consistent actions and clear communication. As a leader, I do my best to ensure that my actions align with my words, and that they consistently demonstrate respect for different perspectives.
This alignment has helped build a foundation of trust, making it easier for employees to share their honest thoughts and feedback. It is tricky as we deal with different personalities and honestly some people who don’t trust anyone. Distrustful employees are less likely to engage in open communication or collaborative efforts making the challenge even more difficult. Addressing this issue requires building trust without necessarily knowing or disclosing the full reasons behind the lack of trust.
My experience in many situations involving an untrusting employee has a direct correlation with that person being untrustworthy themselves. This is a bit nuanced, and research has shown some correlation, but not necessarily a straightforward relationship. My experience would suggest that people who are less trusting project their own tendencies onto others and is something leaders should always be mindful of.
Often it can be difficult to balance transparency and confidentiality. Many times, I have possessed information that was crucial to a decision or policy that was made but because of legal, ethical, or even to save someone embarrassment, the information is not shareable. This can also create a perception of opacity and exacerbate feelings of distrust among employees. These situations are very frustrating and have cost me a lot of sleep in my career. These moments require navigating a delicate line between providing enough information to maintain trust and saying to much that could be harmful to someone or even unlawful.
Encouraging Diverse Perspectives
In the story, the emperor's court is filled with yes-men who are too afraid to speak the truth. This is a survival instinct where individuals suppress their own opinions or concerns in favor of maintaining a favorable image. This lack of diverse perspectives contributes to the emperor’s misguided decisions. A culture of psychological safety thrives on diverse viewpoints and inclusive dialogue.
Organizational culture plays a critical role in the prevalence of yes-men, and this stifles innovation and leads to suboptimal decision-making within the organization. Leaders should actively seek out and value different perspectives, recognizing that diverse opinions contribute to better decision-making and innovation. Addressing this issue requires fostering an environment where diverse opinions are valued and where employees feel safe expressing differing views without fear of retribution.
Our organization has tried to bring in different perspectives in a myriad of ways. We have our Leadership Council who the administration team works with to get employee direction and feedback from. Our Safety Committee works on problems regarding workplace safety as well as workplace overall well-being. Our Chieftains represent our different teams and bring ideas and perspectives to the social aspects of our organization. These are just a few ways we have successfully encouraged different perspectives.
Conclusion
The Emperor's New Clothes serves as a poignant reminder of the consequences of failing to cultivate an environment of trust and psychological safety. For leaders, the story underscores the importance of creating a space where employees feel secure in speaking the truth and offering feedback. By modeling vulnerability, building trust through consistent actions, and valuing diverse perspectives, leaders can avoid the pitfalls of vanity and deception, and instead foster a culture of openness and continuous improvement. In doing so, they not only enhance their leadership effectiveness but also empower their teams to thrive.
Comments